Browse Categories
Shopping Cart
Your cart is empty.
Mailing Lists

Local Cheeses

All of our local cheeses are made in this region of the country, with the majority of them coming from Holmes County, Ohio, the heart of Amish Country.
 
 
Displaying products 1 - 30 of 38 results
Page 1 of 2 Page 12movenext
Ohio Swiss (1lb)
Price: $6.99
Ohio Swiss (1lb)
This is our #1 cheese seller and Grandpa's favorite. This cheese is the kind of cheese that Grandpa Yarman started his original store with all those years ago.
4 in 1 Cheese (1lb)
Price: $7.95
4 in 1 Cheese (1lb)
This is 4 mild cheeses in 1! They are Colby, Monterey Jack, Colby Jack, and a Mild Cheddar. A perfect variety for cheese and crackers!!
Aged Provolone (1lb)
Price: $18.95
Aged Provolone (1lb)
American (1lb)
Price: $5.99
American (1lb)
Beer Cheese (1lb)
Price: $10.95
Beer Cheese (1lb)
This cheese was created in Germany, but now it is known worldwide. It is a quite pungent, stalted cheese. It ripens for a period of seven months in highly humid conditions.
Bergenost (Triple Butter Cheese) (1lb)
Price: $9.95
ratingratingratingratingrating
Bergenost (Triple Butter Cheese) (1lb)
Bergenost is a semi-soft cheese with a mild, smooth flavor and a subtle hint of sourness.
Black Diamond (1lb)
Price: Out of Stock
Black Diamond (1lb)
Black Diamond Cheddar is our sharpest cheddar. It is aged for 2 years and is perfect if you like sharp cheeses.
Blazin' Mango Cheddar (1lb)
Price: $9.95
ratingratingratingratingrating
Blazin' Mango Cheddar (1lb)
This cheddar is a combination of fruity mango and fiery habaneros. The sweetness of mango is the first flavor to hit your mouth, followed by the heat of the habaneros.
Blue Cheese (1lb)
Price: $15.95
Blue Cheese (1lb)
Brick (1lb)
Price: $5.99
Brick (1lb)
Brick cheese is a medium-soft cheese that crumbles easily and is somewhat sticky to the knife. Brick cheese is well-suited to slicing for sandwiches, specifically grilled cheese sandwiches, or appetizers and also melts well.
Canadian Cheddar (1lb)
Price: $9.95
Canadian Cheddar (1lb)
Canadian Cheddar cheese is a sharp white cheddar. This cheese is not quite as sharp as our Black Diamond, but slighly sharper than the Ohio Cheddar.
Cayenne Cheddar (1lb)
Price: $9.95
ratingratingratingratingrating
Cayenne Cheddar (1lb)
This is a creamy orange cheddar cheese that is spiced up with cayenne peppers. This is one that many consider to be one of our hottest cheeses along with our Smoked Habanero Cheddar.
Dill Havarti (Double Butter Cheese) (1lb)
Price: $9.95
Dill Havarti (Double Butter Cheese) (1lb)
This cheese has a buttery taste that is somewhat sweet with real dill added to it. It is a double butter cheese which is slightly less creamier than the Bergenost.
Feta Cheese (1lb)
Price: $9.95
Feta Cheese (1lb)
Feta is a brined curd cheese traditionally made in Greece. Feta is an aged cheese and has a slightly grainy texture. It is used as a table cheese, as well as in salads, pastries and in baking.
Garlic Cheddar (1lb)
Price: $9.95
Garlic Cheddar (1lb)
Our Garlic Cheddar is a creamy white cheddar with garlic added to it. It is great used with pasta, baked & mashed potatoes.
Gouda (1lb)
Price: $10.95
Gouda (1lb)
Havarti (Double Butter Cheese) (1lb)
Price: $8.95
Havarti (Double Butter Cheese) (1lb)
Havarti cheese has a buttery taste that is somewhat sweet. It is a double butter cheese so it is slighly less creamier than our Bergenost.
Horseradish Bacon Cheddar (1lb)
Price: $9.95
ratingratingratingratingrating
Horseradish Bacon Cheddar (1lb)
This is a creamy white cheddar cheese with real smoked bacon and tangy horseradish mixed throughout.
Horseradish Cheddar (1lb)
Price: $9.95
ratingratingratingratingrating
Horseradish Cheddar (1lb)
This is a creamy white cheddar with a distinct tangy horseradish flavor.
Limburger (8 oz.)
Price: $6.95
Limburger (8 oz.)
Limburger is especially known for its pungent odor. it is mostly creamy and smooth.
unavailable
Maple Cheddar (1lb)
Price: Discontinued
Maple Cheddar (1lb)
Mozzarella (1lb)
Price: $5.99
Mozzarella (1lb)
This cheese is most famous for being used as a favorite pizza topping by many. It is very creamy and very mild.
Muenster (1lb)
Price: $5.99
ratingratingratingratingrating
Muenster (1lb)
Muenster is a smooth textured cheese with an orange rind and a white interior. It has a very mild flavor and smooth, soft texture.
Ohio Baby Swiss (1lb)
Price: $6.99
Ohio Baby Swiss (1lb)
Baby Swiss is a close relative to Ohio Swiss except has a milder taste and smooth, creamy texture. It also has smaller "eyes", which is the common term used for the holes in Swiss cheese.
Ohio Cheddar (1lb)
Price: $9.95
Ohio Cheddar (1lb)
This is the mildest of our plain cheddar cheeses. It would be the perfect touch to any of your favorite recipes.
Ohio Colby (1lb)
Price: $5.99
Ohio Colby (1lb)
Colby is a soft, moist, and mild cheese. It can be grated and top a variety of recipes.
Ohio Marble (1lb)
Price: $5.99
ratingratingratingratingrating
Ohio Marble (1lb)
Our Ohio Marble cheese is a blend of Ohio Colby and Ohio Farmer's cheese. This cheese tends to be the kids favorite!
Page 1 of 2 Page 12movenext